🧭 Petition Overview
-
A petition launched on MoveOn.org demands that First Lady Melania Trump, her parents Viktor and late Amalija Knavs, and their son Barron be among the first to be deported under Donald Trump’s proposed immigration policies targeting naturalized citizens.
-
Organizers argue Trump’s “no exceptions” stance must apply to his own family, saying: “If this is truly about national security, then Melania needs to go!”.
🧾 Petition Details & Signatures
-
Originally launched months ago, the petition surged in recent weeks—gaining nearly 3,000 signatures by July 2.
-
Other reports suggest it has amassed 45,000+ signatures, reflecting a wave of public interest amid the harsh immigration rhetoric.
📚 Background: The Trumps’ Immigration History
-
Melania Trump was born in Slovenia in 1970, moved to the U.S. in 1996, received an EB‑1 “extraordinary ability” visa in 2001, and became a U.S. citizen in 2006—five years after marrying Donald Trump.
-
Her parents gained citizenship via family-based immigration—nicknamed “chain migration”—a system Trump has personally criticized.
-
Barron Trump, born in 2006 in the U.S., is automatically a citizen by birthright.
🔍 Political Reaction & Hypocrisy Allegations
-
Critics and petitioners frame the petition as highlighting “blatant hypocrisy,” urging equal application of Trump’s own policies to his family.
-
Rep. Maxine Waters publicly urged scrutiny of Melania’s immigration background, questioning her family’s documented status—a message echoed in the petition.
-
Rep. Jasmine Crockett also downplayed Melania’s EB‑1 credentials, calling them politically convenient rather than earned.
⚖️ Legal Feasibility
-
There is no legal path under U.S. law to deport a naturalized citizen simply because of their political views.
-
Removing citizenship requires serious criminal deception at the time of naturalization—not related to policy disagreements or public dissatisfaction.
🚨 Wider Context: Trump’s Immigration Drive
-
This petition emerges amid Trump’s intensified immigration enforcement push:
-
A Justice Department memo enabling denaturalization for certain crimes.
-
Trump’s threats of deportation against political opponents.
-
Supreme Court rulings enabling tightened birthright citizenship rules.
-
🔍 Final Takeaways
-
The petition is fundamentally a political statement, underscoring perceived double standards in Trump’s immigration agenda.
-
It lacks legal grounding to effect deportation of Melania, her parents, or Barron, all of whom hold U.S. citizenship or were born here.
-
Nonetheless, the petition has sparked a broader debate over fairness, rule of law, and the extent to which policymakers enforce their own rules.
